The Bold and the Beautiful Spoilers: Sheila Framed by Twisted Sisters? (2024)

Bold and the Beautiful has Sheila Carter as the murderer in the eyes of almost everyone she knows, including her son on the CBS soap. But while Sheila looks suspicious, many B&B fans don’t believe she’s the culprit.

But a couple of sisters look suspicious, and it sounds like they have something that Sheila Carter does not have so far… a motive.

The Bold and the Beautiful Spoilers: Paving the Way for Sheila Carter?

Sheila Carter (Kimberlin Brown) is humiliated as she’s carted off by Lt. Baker (Dan Martin) for questioning in a double death. Bold and the Beautiful spoilers have Deacon Sharpe (Sean Kanan) soon in misery from the fallout of two people dying in his restaurant.

So, not only is his wife suspected in two murders, but he’s about to be short on customers, which is a huge hit to his livelihood. The allegations that put Sheila as the murderer likely takes a big chunk out of his business.

Then there’s Sheila Carter, who feels betrayed by her son, Finn. She looked shocked as John Finnegan (Tanner Novlan) suddenly joined his wife’s campaign to have Sheila Carter put away.

So life looks grim for Sheila Carter and her new husband as Bold and the Beautiful rolls out next week. However, a new theory suggests this is all part of the soap laying the groundwork for Sheila’s redemption.

B&B Spoilers: Sheila the Victim of Manipulating Sisters?

which might be the foundation for a much bigger story for John Finnegan and Sheila Carter’s future. So, this may lead to a twist in the storyline. And it’s something fans thought they would never see.

There may come a time when Bold and Beautiful has Sheila spending quality time with her son. Maybe even Steffy sees things differently down the line as well.

While still proceeding with caution, we might see Steffy join in on family time with Finn’s birth mother. Okay, this could sound like a fairy tale plucked right out of The Bold and the Beautiful‘s bag of strange happenings.

But it would make an interesting fate for Sheila if it rang true. The soap could always pull her out of the land of good and put her back on the road to evil again at any time. So, maybe even a short vacation from evil is on the way for Sheila.

The theory goes that Li Finnegan (Naomi Matsuda) is the killer. Possibly, with the help of Poppy Nozawa (Romy Park). If Poppy didn’t participate, she may know that her sister did this. So, if this is the case, then things could change drastically.

Some versions also have Jack Finnegan (Ted King) with his hand in this. All three would be very invested in keeping a secret about their children.

Bold and the Beautiful Spoilers: Li Finnegan & Poppy Nozawa Protect Their Kids?

This theory has another theory attached to it, which has nothing to do with Sheila. This first theory happened long ago and it gives the sisters a motive or two for wanting Tom Starr and Hollis (Hollis W. Chambers) dead. That Finn as Luna’s father, not Bill Spencer (Don Diamont).

Finn and his Aunt Poppy are close in age, but since her sister adopted him, they are not blood relatives. So, fans learned a while back on Bold and Beautiful that Poppy moved in with her sister’s family decades ago. Back then, she and Finn spent a lot of time together. Maybe too much time.

Fans suggest that this goes way back for these two sisters. So here goes with the first theory… It happened one night when Finn was just a teen, Poppy and Finn did the deed, or so the theory suggests. And the outcome of this deed was baby Luna Nozawa (Lisa Yamada).

Bold and the Beautiful already established that Finn and Poppy sometimes danced the night away back in the day. This theory also suggested Poppy’s special mints left him with no memory of the night together that spawned Luna.

So, Li, Poppy, and possibly even Jack Finneganhave buried Luna’s true paternity for two decades. For this theory to work, Li Finnegan had to tamper with the DNA test she gave Bill and her niece.

B&B Spoilers: Trouble Shows Up

When Tom Starr shows up claiming to be Luna’s father, this starts the ball rolling. If anyone should hear his claims, then another DNA test would blow open their secret of 20-plus years. Once Hollis found evidence in that backpack leading to why Tom was murdered, he too had to go.

With Sheila hated by so many people, it looks as if Li Finnegan devised a plan to pin the murders on the woman with nine toes. This way she gets rid of the woman causing her family so much trouble as well as the two men who knew her secret.

Poppy may or may not have joined her sister in this mission. But she also has a lot at stake, so there’s certainly a motive for both sisters to kill Tom and Hollis.

Bold and the Beautiful: Sheila’s Road to Redemption?

So, there you have it, this second theory has Bold and the Beautiful fans witnessing the first step in the redemption of Sheila Carter. While it’s not looking like Sheila murdered Tom or Hollis, things can flip like a switch.

When the truth comes out, Finn will find it hard to forgive himself for disowning Sheila Carter. Even Steffy threw in a little blurb this week that she might have bought her wicked mother-in-law’s changed-person campaign.

So, a little guilt about the things said and done to Finn’s birth mother, might get Sheila’s foot in the front door if this theory holds true. So she may get to enjoy her son, grandson, and daughter-in-law as she always dreamed.

That said, no matter which way the CBS soap takes this storyline, you can bet there’s some twist about to jump out when fans least suspect.

Head back to Soap Dirt for the latest spoilers from The Bold and the Beautiful.